Many types of software have fostered devoted online communities, but perhaps none more so than gaming. Although Stack Overflow or Github represent amazing achievements of collective engagement, there aren't many people who'd sit for hours watching a Twitch-style stream of somebody else programming or using Excel.

More specifically, the gaming community's enthusiasm for social learning from expert players is really interesting. This takes both unstructured and structured forms. By unstructured forms, I mean activities like watching a game with expert commentary, discussing techniques with other fans, or reading general strategy guides. By structured forms, I mean identifying and making use of specific, replicable artifacts or approaches. Examples might include:

• a StarCraft build order that explicitly identifies when to build certain units and structures;
• a Cities Skylines district layout that optimises population happiness while minimising traffic;
• a Kerbal Space Program rocket design that maximises payload for a given budget;
• a Mario Kart driving route that is the fastest possible for a given track.

These structured approaches can be thought of 'expert systems': ways of domain experts encoding their knowledge into models that can then be implemented more broadly.

Learning from expert users

But doing the encoding is only half the battle. For these models to have maximum usefulness, it needs to be easy to consume them. Games could lend themselves neatly to trialling new approaches here. Take the Mario Kart example. Mario Kart has long implemented a 'ghost' driver, a hazily visible competitor that re-enacts the path you drove during your previous best time on the same track. What if Mario Kart instead allowed you to select from ghosts generated by experts, so that you could practice following their ideal routes? What if this ghost mode also gave you a preview of what buttons they were about to push as they approached a tight corner or avoided a hazard? This would provide a powerful means of assisted "learning by doing". There’s even a kind of ghost in the physical world: wavelight texhnology used for pacing elite runners.

Wavelight running technology

Working through the other examples, imagine:

• a StarCraft UI that provides real-time building advice based on a professional-level build order, selected by the player from a library;
• a Cities Skylines UI that ghosts in a faint outline of potential roads, buildings and zones based on a set of expert-created districts;
• a Kerbal Space Program UI that lets you use another player's design as a translucent starting point, and provides feedback on how your work in progress differs from their reference.

In some cases, the expert reference may even be generated by an AI rather than a human. AlphaStar is better than (almost) any human at StarCraft — how about tapping it to help novice players learn faster?

This 'ghost' approach is more useful in some games than others. I think the build layout examples of StarCraft or Cities Skylines are more compelling than the other examples. But the point is that in many cases, it might be possible to incorporate this expert guidance more directly into the game's UI, rather than relying solely on novice players absorbing information outside the game and then trying to remember how to apply it as they play.

Assistive product rails

This approach generalises beyond games, too. Almost all pieces of complex software currently rely on outside training and learning rather than high-quality assistive rails within the UI. Macros and similar tools can allow domain experts to encode and share their knowledge and workflow. But the technical skill bar for generating these is usually high, and there are many more domain experts than programmers in most enterprises.

An approach inspired by 'ghosts' from gaming might incorporate features like:

• Allowing an expert user to record a "workflow ghost" macro as an arbitrary set of input actions taken within the program, and then publish it for other users. Other users could opt to execute it with one click (like a pure macro), or to step through it on-screen with a 'follow the bouncing ball' UI, so they can see and learn what it's doing. Some applications do allow this kind of macro recording - but very few.